My Insipid Record Collection – The Lemonheads

I couldn’t get enough of It’s a Shame About Ray when it was released in 1992. It wasn’t only the title track either. Songs like “Confetti, My Drug Buddy and Rudderless” (even the much reviled cover of Simon & Garfunkel’s “Mrs Robinson”) made this record a must own back then. It was an Alternative Rock programmer’s dream; it had folk, rock, melody, a breeziness and it was catchy as all get out. The Lemonheads had been around since 1986 and had really never risen above Indie status before their sixth record (including EPs), It’s a Shame About Ray, was released. They had a following, don’t get me wrong, but it just seemed like their popularity exploded in 1992. As far as I was concerned, it was with good reason.
If I understand the chain of events, the “Mrs Robinson” cover was almost an accident as it was recorded to promote the video release of the classic 1967 movie soundtrack The Graduate featuring Dustin Hoffman, Anne Bancroft and Katharine Ross. It also appeared on the soundtrack to 1993′s Wayne’s World 2, but by then it was anticlimactic. The band was annoyed that it was released at all, but it became so popular that they had to reissue the Ray CD and include it because so many people like me bought the original CD, sans “Mrs Robinson,” and were disappointed to find it was later reissued. I just went out and bought the CD single My Drug Buddy (which included ”Mrs Robinson”) to remedy the situation, but it was annoying to me as well. I can so remember getting singed a few years prior with XTC’s Skylarking when it failed to originally include the single “Dear God.” The point is, while it is my understanding that The Lemonheads weren’t thrilled with ”Mrs Robinson” they are still playing it on the radio to this day. I can take it or leave it, but it’s not better than any of the other songs I mentioned above and I’m a mad Simon & Garfunkel fan. I grew up with those boys. Folk at its very best.
Chief Lemonhead Evan Dando became a popular face beyond his wildest expectations as a result of the genius of It’s a Shame About Ray. The record was so strong it seemed to somehow fit right in with the Alice in Chains, Nirvana, Pearl Jam and Soundgarden fare of the day. Dando appeared even made People Magazine’s 50 Most Beautiful that year. Heady stuff for a guy who allegedly had a taste for the drug world. He had created his own musical category if memory serves called “Bubblegrunge.” How awesome is that? Call it whatever you want, but I loved it. I was very disappointed when they couldn’t even come close to duplicating this record. 1993′s Come On Feel The Lemonheads had a nice single “Into Your Arms,” but ultimately the record fell flat. They had half a dozen decent singles between 1987 and 1996 (see their cover of Suzanne Vega’s “Luka” for instance), but I just can’t help but think they could have done better. That’s just my opinion of course. I’ve never written a single song so I have no business criticizing anyone.
I know I’ve been posting more than one song in most of my posts, which I’m sure is good news to MP3 surfers, but this is a record I sort of want to post four songs so I’m going to. If you somehow missed these the first time around; you’re welcome. I could use some supportive comments though; the one’s I’ve been getting lately are coming from aggravated artists and fans after I’ve reluctantly labeled someone a potential one hit wonder. I hope you like these songs as much as I do.
The Lemonheads – It’s a Shame About Ray.mp3
The Lemonheads – Rudderless.mp3
The Lemonheads – My Drug Buddy.mp3
The Lemonheads - My Drug Buddy.mp3 YSI
Buy or download It’s a Shame About Ray from Amazon here.
| This entry was posted by John Jay on January 19, 2010 at 11:40 pm, and is filed under My Insipid Record Collection. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site. |









about 7 months ago
Don’t take this too badly, but I just have to disagree about “Come On Feel”. That’s my favourite Lemonheads album, and I think it’s more varied and inspired than It’s A Shame About Ray. Songs like “Dawn Can’t Decide”, “Paid to Smile”, “It’s About Time”, “I’ll Do It Anyway” cram four or five melodic and rhythmic ideas into a 2 to 3 minute song while most people struggle to fit 2 ideas in.
However, do keep up the good work, and don’t get discouraged!
about 7 months ago
Hey Neil – Thank you very much for your kind words. You know, I went to Amazon and read the reviews on Come On Feel and noticed many of them agreed with you. I just remembered the record didn’t seem to have the radio legs after they played “Great Big No” and I’m going to admit right here and now that I may not have given the record my usual 15-20 listens all the way through (My rule before they head to my own personal Wall(s) of Fame) so I am going to take your opinion under advisement. I was cranking out mixed cassette tapes at an alarming rate in those days and sometimes I grabbed the hit and moved on. Guilty as charged if that is the case here. I really appreciate you reading and for the classy way you presented your thoughts. I get a lot of tantrums here, as you can imagine, and what does anything I say really matter after twenty, thirty or even forty years right? It’s not like I’m affecting CD sales or anything. That said I know how it feels to have one of my favorite nobody loves it but me records tossed into the ideological cut out bin of musical life so I take your opinion seriously. Thanks so much for reading my friend!
about 7 months ago
Don’t underestimate the tremendous backlash against Evan Dando, including the “Die Evan Dando, Die” zine produced in the Summer of 1993, that produced 3,000 copies and had a write up in Time, Newsweek, Rolling Stone, Spin, etc. as part of their underachieving status. Sadly, perhaps my two favorite cuts are the two covers, edging them towards UB40 status, the BubbleReggae band to the Lemonheads BubbleGrunge (or alterna-pop). Speaking of which I always wondered, could a UB40 cover-band exist? Essentially a cover-band of a band that is a cover band – a true oxy-moron.
Anyway, a 2003 Boston Phoenix article entitled Forgive and Forget spoke to your points on Evan Dando/The Lemonheads.
http://www.bostonphoenix.com/boston/music/other_stories/documents/02827374.htm
Oh and here is a link to the story on the zine producer
http://www.viceland.com/int/v16n10/htdocs/i-accidentally-made-a-zine-162.php
Keep up the good work Johnny!